Princess Peach: Showtime marks a significant return for Nintendo's beloved princess after nearly two decades since her last leading role in 2006's Super Princess Peach. This game serves as a platform to further develop Peach's individuality apart from Mario and solidify her position as the ruler of the Mushroom Kingdom. However, amidst the new faces introduced in Princess Peach: Showtime, a notable absence is felt – Toadsworth, one of Peach's closest allies, missing from recent Mario titles.

While Princess Peach: Showtime introduces a fresh ensemble cast, such as Theets and the Sour Bunch, the inclusion of Toads as Peach's companions hints at a larger Mario series connection. Yet, the omission of Toadsworth, a pivotal character, is a glaring oversight in a game that could have seamlessly integrated him.

An Overlooked Opportunity

Longtime fans of the Mario franchise will recognize Toadsworth, Princess Peach's loyal steward first appearing in Super Mario Sunshine on the GameCube. Despite his minor role in that game, Toadsworth's presence as a dependable advisor to Peach resonated with players. His absence in recent Mario titles, except for re-releases, diminishes his significance, especially considering his involvement in Peach's prior adventures.

Princess Peach: Showtime could have easily reinvigorated its narrative by incorporating Toadsworth, leveraging his established bond with Peach and enriching the gameplay experience.

Imagining Toadsworth's Return

Toadsworth's seamless inclusion in Princess Peach: Showtime could have been a nod to his past roles as Peach's trusted companion. Whether as Peach's escort to Sparkle Theater or a character in need of rescue from adversaries, Toadsworth's reemergence would have added depth to the storyline and honored his longstanding alliance with Peach.

By overlooking Toadsworth in Princess Peach: Showtime, the game missed a chance to infuse familiarity and depth, embodying a character dynamic that fans have cherished throughout the Mario series.