Disney and Pixar Struggle with Animation Innovation

A comparison to other animation studios reveals Disney and Pixar's lack of visual progress.
Disney and Pixar Struggle with Animation Innovation

Highlights

  • Disney's recent movies, such as "Wish" and "Strange World," have underperformed critically and commercially, leading to a lack of confidence in upcoming sequels.
  • Disney's animation quality has stagnated, with the same 3D style being used for movie after movie, while other animation studios continue to innovate and push the genre forward.
  • Disney and Pixar's struggle to innovate and move past their fundamental animation tools has left them falling behind in comparison to films like "Into the Spider-Verse" that offer unique and visually stunning animation styles.

Disney’s recent movies, including the big hundredth-anniversary event movie, 'Wish,' and 2022's 'Strange World,' have not met expectations critically and commercially. This has resulted in waning confidence in the upcoming sequels from Disney and Pixar. With an emphasis on existing franchises such as 'Toy Story 5,' 'Frozen 3,' and 'Cars 4,' and the reworked television series-based 'Moana 2,' many perceive the corporation as being in a state of desperation.

While Disney faces various challenges, one frequently cited issue is the stagnation in the animation quality of their movies. The transition from hand-drawn to 3D animation has led to a lack of visual innovation, in contrast to the dynamic evolution seen across the animation landscape. This represents a significant setback for Disney and Pixar, who played a pivotal role in the establishment of animated cinema.

Disney's Historic Contributions to Animation

Disney played a pivotal role in the commercialization of animation. While 'Snow White and The Seven Dwarfs' is often regarded as the first animated film, its status as such is contested by historians. However, it undeniably marked the first profitable animated feature film, propelling Disney to the forefront of the animation movement.

Disney's innovative techniques revolutionized animation, maintaining their prominence through the release of films like 'Fantasia,' '101 Dalmations,' 'Alice in Wonderland,' 'The Lion King,' 'Beauty and the Beast,' and 'Princess and The Frog.' Additionally, Pixar's 'Toy Story' marked a significant leap with the first entirely computer-animated feature film, solidifying Disney's influence in animation.

Disney and Pixar's Struggle to Innovate

Disney's pursuit of realism in animation, once revolutionary, now appears uninspired. Their struggle to move beyond fundamental animation tools has become apparent, particularly when compared to the groundbreaking animation styles introduced by films like 'Into the Spider-Verse.'

While 'The Incredibles 2' showcased impressive technical details, 'Into the Spider-Verse' presented a completely new and visually striking animation style. The latter's unique approach not only captivated audiences but also outshone 'The Incredibles 2' in terms of storytelling and themes, highlighting the allure of distinct visuals.

Subsequent animated movies, such as 'The Mitchells vs The Machines,' 'Puss In Boots: The Last Wish,' and 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem,' have embraced similar innovative styles, while Disney and Pixar have seemingly reached an impasse. Their productions, while technically impressive, lack the uniqueness seen in their earlier works and are criticized for character similarities, particularly among female protagonists.

Furthermore, Disney's attempts at innovation, such as the rumored hand-drawn animated movie 'Wish,' which turned out to be a 3D production mimicking traditional animation, have not yielded the expected results. The film's lackluster visuals have left fans yearning for the nostalgic charm that once defined Disney's animation.