Games

The Argument For and Against Introducing a New Lead in Dead Space 4

The future Dead Space installment may consider abandoning Isaac Clarke, a decision that could bring both advantages and disadvantages.
The Argument For and Against Introducing a New Lead in Dead Space 4

Highlights

  • The ambiguous conclusion of Dead Space 3 sets the stage for a potential sequel, leaving Isaac Clarke's fate open for exploration.
  • Isaac's character has endured significant physical and psychological trauma throughout the series, making it reasonable to consider new protagonists and storylines.
  • While a fresh lead could inject new vitality into the franchise, Isaac should not be overlooked, and if he does return in Dead Space 4, his role should be thoughtfully handled.

With the future of the Dead Space franchise in flux, the successful reboot from last year may pave the way for forthcoming games in the series. If EA progresses with the franchise through a follow-up to Dead Space 3, critical decisions will need to be made regarding the overarching storyline, given the inconclusive ending of DS3. Among these pivotal plot choices is the fate of series mainstay, Isaac Clarke.

The ending of Dead Space 3 leaves numerous unanswered questions. Isaac and his partner, John Carver, seemingly sacrifice themselves to thwart the Brethren Moons from triggering the Convergence event. However, the 'true' ending in the Awakened DLC reveals that the duo survives. After an unsuccessful attempt to prevent the Brethren Moons from assaulting Earth, Isaac and John witness their home planet being devoured by two Brethren Moons, abruptly concluding the game and the Dead Space franchise.

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Replacing Isaac in Dead Space 4

Isaac Clarke's Saga Is Incomplete

While the return of Dead Space's beloved protagonist would undoubtedly please many fans, there's a case to be made for the necessity of Isaac's comeback from a narrative standpoint. Dead Space 3's conclusion, while fittingly bleak, lacks closure or clarity. The apocalyptic event at the end of DS3, where Earth is besieged by the Brethren Moons, leaves too many loose ends, hinting at a potential sequel rather than a definitive conclusion.

Consequently, the tale of Dead Space, and by extension, Isaac's story, feels unresolved. The tradition of concluding the game with Isaac on a ship is upheld, but in this instance, he is flying into immediate danger. The narrative of Dead Space 4 would need to address the Brethren Moon storyline, depict Earth's fate, and deliver a fitting conclusion to Isaac's narrative, possibly exploring the status of his relationship with Ellie and his eventual fate.

Dead Space 4 Could Offer Isaac a Reprieve

Horror narratives typically lack uplifting moments, and Isaac Clarke has endured a remarkable amount of suffering throughout the Dead Space franchise, bordering on the verge of dark comedy. The character's relentless physical and psychological torment, coupled with dashed opportunities for happiness, suggests that having him as the central figure in Dead Space 4 might feel repetitive. Therefore, it might be prudent to conclude Isaac's story and pass the baton to a new character with distinct challenges to surmount.

Whether the upcoming game in the series represents a soft reboot of the Dead Space narrative or a direct extension of the original trilogy, it should address Isaac in some capacity. Introducing a new protagonist could infuse fresh vigor into the franchise, but it is imperative not to overlook Isaac. If he does headline Dead Space 4, his involvement should be carefully managed.

Tags:
Share:
Recent News