Persona 3 Reload is the latest installment in Atlus' series, originating as a remake of a 2006 Japanese release. Subsequently, it received two different versions: Persona 3 FES, a PS2 upgrade that added an epilogue, and Persona 3 Portable, a PSP port that introduced a female protagonist among other changes.
Persona 3 Reload brings significant changes, propelling the series beyond Persona 5, the latest numbered sequel. While Persona 5 garnered rave reviews, how does it measure up against Persona 3 Reload? Is this remake superior to Persona 5?
Social Stat Limitations
Streamlined Social Stats in Persona 3 Reload
In the original Persona 3 and its remake, players could level up their Academics, Courage, and Charm Social Stats, unlike the sequels which introduced five Social Stats. Returning to only three options in this remake felt like a breath of fresh air after playing through Persona 4 and Persona 5.
The simpler approach to Social Stats in Persona 3 Reload is less stressful, considering the game's complexity and the plethora of choices in Persona 5. While the latter offers substantial value and replayability, the streamlined approach in Persona 3 Reload is more manageable.
More Freedom
No Overbearing Companion in Persona 3 Reload
Unlike Persona 5, which introduced a constant companion in the form of Morgana, Persona 3 Reload allows players more freedom without constant guidance. The absence of a persistent advisor and lengthy updates about the plot makes Persona 3 Reload less overwhelming compared to Persona 5.
Koromaru Vs Morgana
Comparing Companion Characters
Introducing animals as significant party members, Persona 3 featured Koromaru, a wolf-like Shiba Inu, while Persona 4 had Teddie, a bear concealing a teen boy. Persona 5's Morgana, although appearing as a normal cat in the real world, has an off-putting alternative form in dungeons and constant nagging, making Koromaru a more endearing companion.
One Continuous Dungeon
Seamless Gameplay in Persona 3 Reload
Persona 3 featured one main dungeon, Tartarus, with randomized floors, offering a straightforward experience compared to Persona 5's intricate Palaces. Reverting to one dungeon in Persona 3 Reload and the enhancements to Tartarus' design provide a more streamlined gameplay experience.
The Battle Upgrades
Refinements in Persona 3 Reload's Battle System
Persona 5 introduced the Baton Pass mechanic, while Persona 3 Reload incorporated a similar feature called Shift, not tied to Social Links, providing a small advantage. Additionally, the introduction of Theurgies in Persona 3 Reload enhances the battle system.
Summoning Persona
The Edgy Evoker in Persona 3 Reload
While the Evoker in Persona 3 was initially controversial, it remains the most striking Persona summoning method in the series. Compared to Persona 4 and Persona 5's summoning practices, Persona 3's approach stands out, offering a unique and edgy experience.
The Monster Designs
Distinct Villains and Summoning Practices
Persona 5 incorporated elements from the Shin Megami Tensei series, including a questionnaire method for obtaining Personas. In contrast, Persona 3 and the remake feature unique monsters and a more coherent Persona acquisition process, aligning with the approach in Persona 4.